• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Fierce Patriots

Conservative Political News

  • Subscribe

<![CDATA[Freedom Foundation]]>

Southern States Moving Bills to Reinforce Janus Ruling

March 22, 2023 by Freedom Foundation Leave a Comment

Rusty Brown is the Southern Director of the Freedom Foundation. 

On paper, the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark 2018 ruling in Janus v. AFSCME banned mandatory union membership and dues in the public workforce. But in the years since it was issued, lower courts have demonstrated little stomach for enforcing the decision, emboldening union leaders to simply behave as though it never happened.

That could change soon, as several cases that could put some teeth in Janus are currently under consideration by the current justices. In the meantime, however, at least four states — Florida, Kentucky, Tennessee, and Oklahoma — are moving ahead with measures intended to enforce exactly what the ruling says.

In Florida, Republicans in the state Legislature are working to exploit supermajorities in both houses in order to enact a bill whose language mirrors that of the Janus ruling, with a few extra surprises thrown in for good measure.

Since first being heard on March 7, the Senate version has cleared its second and final committee with the next stop being the Senate floor. The House bill cleared its first committee on March 16 and has one more committee hearing before proceeding to the house floor and, finally, the governor’s desk.

Meanwhile, in Kentucky, a pair of bills moving through the General Assembly would also take the state out of the dues-collection business.

Senate Bill 7 would stop automatic transfers to political action committees from a public employee’s paycheck. House Bill 364 would do the same, in addition to preventing payroll deductions for union membership dues.

House Bill 26 would prohibit public funds from being used by unions for lobbying purposes. In essence, it simply imposes rules that prevent the government from lobbying itself.

Both Kentucky bills have passed through committee and await floor action in their respective chambers.

A recent study revealed that the Kentucky Education Association directs nearly $4 out of every $10 in union dues collected from its members to the National Education Association (NEA), which uses these funds to support partisan liberal political organizations and activities.

As the final version of SB 7 is decided, lawmakers plan to strengthen the bill with an amendment that does what the Florida bill would already do — end all government involvement in transmitting funds directly to unions, including payroll deductions for membership dues.

Next door in Tennessee, a bill authored by Republican Senate Leader Jack Johnson (R-Franklin) requires the Tennessee Department of Education to “publish the annual state salary schedule” on the department website, but an amendment to the bill adds a requirement that would also prohibit union dues from being deducted from teachers’ salaries.

The amendment explicitly prohibits any Local Education Agency (LEA) from deducting dues from an employee’s payroll for any “professional employees’ organization,” or union. Instead, it would be up to the individual employee to pay those voluntarily.

“This section does not prohibit an employee of an LEA from personally and voluntarily remitting dues to a professional employees’ organization,” the bill notes.

Lastly, Oklahoma is also considering a bill that would require union members to opt-in to unions on an annual basis rather than the status quo of being permanently opted in until they request to be let out. Senate Bill 99 builds upon a 2022 Executive order signed by the governor that required teachers be notified that they have a constitutional right not to participate in a union if they choose not to for any reason.

Union caterwauling notwithstanding, nothing being proposed in either state would prevent workers from forming or belonging to a union if they so choose. The legislation would simply make unions responsible for their own dues deductions.

Moreover, while the Florida, Kentucky, Tennessee, and Oklahoma proposals all include provisions not specifically mentioned in the Janus ruling as written by Justice Samuel Alito and affirmed by four of his colleagues, each is entirely consistent with its unambiguous intent.

The ruling clearly states, “Neither an agency fee nor any other payment to the union may be deducted from a nonmember’s wages, nor may any other attempt be made to collect such a payment, unless the employee affirmatively consents to pay.”

What better way to ensure public employees do, in fact, agree to support their union than by making them directly responsible for paying dues rather than allowing the state to deduct it preemptively at the union’s behest?

When unions are allowed to outsource their own billing and collection activities to a taxpayer-supported state agency, pretty soon it starts to feel like the money belongs to them instead of the worker who earned it.

It’s time unions were reminded which side is working for the other.

The opinions expressed in guest op-eds are those of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of RedState.com.

Filed Under: <![CDATA[Conservatism]]>, <![CDATA[Florida]]>, <![CDATA[Freedom Foundation]]>, <![CDATA[janus vs. afscme]]>, <![CDATA[Kentucky]]>, <![CDATA[Oklahoma]]>, <![CDATA[Public Unions]]>, <![CDATA[Tennessee]]>, <![CDATA[Unions]]>, News, Red State

Primary Sidebar

Jim Jordan: Is Alvin Bragg Investigating Hunter’s Anonymous Art Sales in NYC?

March 31, 2023 | Wendell Husebo | Leave a Comment

House Judiciary Committee Chair Jim Jordan (R-OH) questioned if Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg is probing into Hunter Biden’s suspicious art … Read More... about Jim Jordan: Is Alvin Bragg Investigating Hunter’s Anonymous Art Sales in NYC?

‘Grandma’ of California Police Union Charged With Running Domestic Fentanyl Operation

March 31, 2023 | Ben Kew | Leave a Comment

Federal officials have charged the executive director of a police union in California with running a drug operation from her residence and using her … Read More... about ‘Grandma’ of California Police Union Charged With Running Domestic Fentanyl Operation

Media Research Center: Elon Musk’s Twitter Censors *More* than Prior Year

March 31, 2023 | Lucas Nolan | Leave a Comment

The Media Research Center has reported an increase in censorship and harsher penalties for users since Elon Musk took over as CEO of Twitter. Tweets … Read More... about Media Research Center: Elon Musk’s Twitter Censors *More* than Prior Year

Former Air Force sergeant stole suppressors, rocket launcher tubes, classified material, and thousands of bullets from his unit

March 31, 2023 | Andrew Chapados | Leave a Comment

A former Air Force master sergeant pleaded guilty to stealing firearm attachments, ammunition, and even a classified documents during and after his … Read More... about Former Air Force sergeant stole suppressors, rocket launcher tubes, classified material, and thousands of bullets from his unit

‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk’s Twitter Locks Account of New York Post – Again

March 31, 2023 | Alana Mastrangelo | Leave a Comment

Elon Musk’s Twitter locked the New York Post out of its account on Thursday after it posted a story about the social media platform deleting more than … Read More... about ‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk’s Twitter Locks Account of New York Post – Again

Sign Up For The Fierce Patriot Newsletter

Caption this… #letsgobrandon #supplychaincrisis Caption this…
#letsgobrandon #supplychaincrisis #holidayshopping2021
📹 - Credit: @aaronlabrum
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Joe Rogan has nothing but rage for this industry lying to Americans

March 31, 2023 | BlazeTV Staff | Leave a Comment

Dave Rubin discussed Joe Rogan’s recent take on the deterioration of journalism with independent … Read More... about Joe Rogan has nothing but rage for this industry lying to Americans

Videos of middle schoolers fighting in class while teacher is present spur outrage. She responds, ‘What do you want me to do? … Those kids are bigger than me.’

March 31, 2023 | Dave Urbanski | Leave a Comment

Videos of students fighting in a Georgia middle school classroom while a teacher is present have … Read More... about Videos of middle schoolers fighting in class while teacher is present spur outrage. She responds, ‘What do you want me to do? … Those kids are bigger than me.’

Race Hustler Joy Reid Says Criticizing Alvin Bragg Suggests ‘Black Folks Are Controlled’ by ‘Some Jewish Overseer’

March 31, 2023 | Mike Miller | Leave a Comment

MSNBC’s race hustler extraordinaire Joy Reid can connect virtually anything to “racism” with no more … Read More... about Race Hustler Joy Reid Says Criticizing Alvin Bragg Suggests ‘Black Folks Are Controlled’ by ‘Some Jewish Overseer’

Race Hustler Joy Reid Says Criticizing Alvin Bragg Suggests ‘Black Folks Are Controlled’ by ‘Some Jewish Overseer’

March 31, 2023 | Mike Miller | Leave a Comment

MSNBC’s race hustler extraordinaire Joy Reid can connect virtually anything to “racism” with no more … Read More... about Race Hustler Joy Reid Says Criticizing Alvin Bragg Suggests ‘Black Folks Are Controlled’ by ‘Some Jewish Overseer’

Maryland school district says parents cannot opt children out of gender identity lessons

March 31, 2023 | Candace Hathaway | Leave a Comment

Parents with children enrolled at a Maryland school district were outraged after the district … Read More... about Maryland school district says parents cannot opt children out of gender identity lessons

Alan Dershowitz explains why judge may quickly toss out Trump indictment: ‘Foolish, foolish decision’

March 31, 2023 | Chris Enloe | Leave a Comment

Legal scholar Alan Dershowitz explained why he believes the indictment against former President … Read More... about Alan Dershowitz explains why judge may quickly toss out Trump indictment: ‘Foolish, foolish decision’

‘Trans Day of Vengeance’ canceled

March 31, 2023 | Cortney Weil | Leave a Comment

The organizers behind the "Trans Day of Vengeance" scheduled for this weekend have called the event … Read More... about ‘Trans Day of Vengeance’ canceled

The Daily Mirror Goes Full ‘Boston Bomber Groupie’ in Its Coverage of Nashville Shooter

March 31, 2023 | Brad Slager | Leave a Comment

As a sign of just how ill-thought they were at Daily Mirror, there were two attempts and two … Read More... about The Daily Mirror Goes Full ‘Boston Bomber Groupie’ in Its Coverage of Nashville Shooter

The Daily Mirror Goes Full ‘Boston Bomber Groupie’ in Its Coverage of Nashville Shooter

March 31, 2023 | Brad Slager | Leave a Comment

As a sign of just how ill-thought they were at Daily Mirror, there were two attempts and two … Read More... about The Daily Mirror Goes Full ‘Boston Bomber Groupie’ in Its Coverage of Nashville Shooter

Glenn Beck & Tucker Carlson REACT to Trump’s INDICTMENT

March 31, 2023 | BlazeTV Staff | Leave a Comment

Donald Trump has been indicted, and Glenn Beck appeared with Tucker Carlson to discuss the … Read More... about Glenn Beck & Tucker Carlson REACT to Trump’s INDICTMENT

‘The time has come’: Mike Pence calls for federal legislation prescribing death penalty for mass shooters

March 31, 2023 | Andrew Chapados | Leave a Comment

Former Vice President Mike Pence called for federal legislation to be drawn up to punish the … Read More... about ‘The time has come’: Mike Pence calls for federal legislation prescribing death penalty for mass shooters

Leftists Gloat, Celebrate Looming Trump Arrest on Social Media: ‘Happy Indictment Day to You and Yours!’

March 31, 2023 | Amy Furr | Leave a Comment

Two leftist Facebook pages–The Other 98% and Occupy Democrats–are celebrating the recent indictment … Read More... about Leftists Gloat, Celebrate Looming Trump Arrest on Social Media: ‘Happy Indictment Day to You and Yours!’

Copyright © 2023 — FiercePatriots.com • All rights reserved. • Privacy Policy • Terms of Use • Sitemap