• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Fierce Patriots

Conservative Political News

  • Subscribe

<![CDATA[Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act]]>

Third Circuit decision not the gun control victory Phil Murphy claims it is

August 18, 2023 by Cam Edwards Leave a Comment

If you only went by the statements of New Jersey politicians, it would be easy to think that the Third Circuit Court of Appeals decision to overturn a trial court judge and re-instate the public nuisance law targeting gun makers and dealers was based on some kind of determination about the law’s constitutionality.

Gov. Phil Murphy congratulated the Attorney General’s office for “winning this important victory in court,” while New Jersey AG Matthew Platkin proclaimed to be “thrilled that a unanimous Third Circuit panel rejected the challenge to New Jersey’s public nuisance law.” Platkin went on to call the law “an important public safety tool”; an ironic statement of epic proportions given why the Third Circuit ruled the way it did.

The three-judge panel didn’t uphold the New Jersey law on its merits. Instead, as the opinion makes clear from the get-go, the ruling is all about the timing of the lawsuit, not the constitutionality of the law itself.

Federal courts are not forecasters. The Constitution limits our jurisdiction to disputes that have ripened fully. We may not prejudge hypothetical cases or offer legal advice. Instead, parties must first be injured before coming to us for redress. Only then do we react. When constitutional rights are at stake, we accelerate that timeline—but only slightly. We may hear a case before a person’s rights are violated only if the threat is imminent. The National Shooting Sports Foundation challenges a new state gun law as violating its members’ constitutional rights. But we see little evidence that enforcement is looming. Because the Foundation has jumped the gun, its challenge must be dismissed.

Now, I happen to disagree with the Third Circuit panel about the imminent threat posed by the New Jersey law. The legislature didn’t pass this law just to “do something”. They want to encourage and empower lawsuits against firearm manufacturers and gun stores for supposedly enticing criminals to do bad things because of their marketing (or, in some cases, their very existence). When anti-gun politicos like Murphy and Platkin are touting how important they think this law is when it comes to public safety, I think it’s a little ridiculous to say that there’s “little evidence” enforcement is looming, but that’s the opinion of the Third Circuit panel.

Pre-enforcement challenges are unusual. To bring one, the plaintiff must show that the stakes are high and close at hand. Normally, that means constitutional rights are at issue, those rights are threatened by significant penalties, and those penalties might well be imposed, as shown by past enforcement in similar situations or some other evidence of the threat. Yet this suit falls far short of even the “normal” preenforcement challenge. A brand-new civil tort statute, without more, does not justify a federal court’s intervention. Because the Foundation’s case is not yet fully formed, we will vacate the preliminary injunction and remand with instructions to dismiss this action for lack of jurisdiction.

Again, the Third Circuit’s decision had nothing to do with the validity of the law in question, only the timing of the National Shooting Sports Foundation’s lawsuit. And as the NSSF’s Larry Keane said in his own statement after the opinion was released, “During oral arguments, the panel appeared to have concerns with the law, as did the district court that enjoined enforcement. Should New Jersey’s attorney general attempt to enforce the law, we will immediately refile our complaint.”

This wasn’t a win for New Jersey, because as soon as Platkin does try to enforce the law NSSF is going to be right back before a judge to ask for an injunction once again and this time there’s no way the appellate court can claim the issue isn’t ripe. The district court has already enjoined the law from being enforced once, and that’s going to be the likely outcome if and when Platkin decides to deploy his “important public safety tool” against the firearms industry.

Filed Under: <![CDATA[Gun Control]]>, <![CDATA[new jersey]]>, <![CDATA[Phil Murphy]]>, <![CDATA[Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act]]>, <![CDATA[public nuisance law]]>, <![CDATA[Video]]>, Bearing Arms, News

Primary Sidebar

The RedState Interview: Lindell Explains How Amex Cut His Credit Limit

September 28, 2023 | Neil W. McCabe | Leave a Comment

The founder and CEO of Chanhassen, Minn.-based MyPillow told RedState the behind-the-scenes details of how American Express kneecapped his business … Read More... about The RedState Interview: Lindell Explains How Amex Cut His Credit Limit

Hunter Biden Referred to Selling Access to Joe Biden as ‘Keys’ to ‘My Family’s Only Asset’

September 28, 2023 | Wendell Husebo | Leave a Comment

Hunter Biden referenced selling access to President Joe Biden as “the keys” to “my family’s only asset,” according to messages from Hunter Biden’s … Read More... about Hunter Biden Referred to Selling Access to Joe Biden as ‘Keys’ to ‘My Family’s Only Asset’

Trump Campaign to RNC After 2nd Fox Debate Goes Haywire: End the Debates, Save Resources for Beating Biden

September 27, 2023 | Hannah Bleau | Leave a Comment

The Trump campaign on Wednesday urged the Republican National Committee (RNC) to end the debates and save resources to defeat President Joe Biden, … Read More... about Trump Campaign to RNC After 2nd Fox Debate Goes Haywire: End the Debates, Save Resources for Beating Biden

Haley: Trump Didn’t Hold China Accountable for COVID, Fentanyl, Cuban Spy Base and Didn’t Stop Land Buys

September 27, 2023 | Ian Hanchett | Leave a Comment

On Wednesday’s broadcast of the Fox News Channel’s “Hannity,” 2024 GOP presidential candidate former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley stated that while … Read More... about Haley: Trump Didn’t Hold China Accountable for COVID, Fentanyl, Cuban Spy Base and Didn’t Stop Land Buys

‘Pointless Screaming Match’: Politicos Rip Chaos-Packed GOP Primary Debate

September 27, 2023 | Nick Gilbertson | Leave a Comment

Politicos from all persuasions found fault with the Republican presidential debate on Wednesday night hosted by Fox News, which devolved into chaos at … Read More... about ‘Pointless Screaming Match’: Politicos Rip Chaos-Packed GOP Primary Debate

Sign Up For The Fierce Patriot Newsletter

Caption this… #letsgobrandon #supplychaincrisis Caption this…
#letsgobrandon #supplychaincrisis #holidayshopping2021
📹 - Credit: @aaronlabrum
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Fox News Picks Univision Host to Push Amnesty in GOP Debate

September 27, 2023 | Neil Munro | Leave a Comment

Fox News’s top executives chose a Colombian-born anchor to host the GOP primary debate and to tout … Read More... about Fox News Picks Univision Host to Push Amnesty in GOP Debate

Trump in Michigan: ‘Only Time Biden Has Gotten His Hands Dirty Is When He’s Taking Cash from Foreign Countries’

September 27, 2023 | John Binder | Leave a Comment

Former President Donald Trump took a swipe at President Joe Biden while speaking to autoworkers in … Read More... about Trump in Michigan: ‘Only Time Biden Has Gotten His Hands Dirty Is When He’s Taking Cash from Foreign Countries’

‘Unwatchable’: Viewers Blast RNC, Fox for Including Univision in Debate

September 27, 2023 | Hannah Bleau | Leave a Comment

Viewers of the second Republican National Committee (RNC) debate blasted the RNC as well as Fox News … Read More... about ‘Unwatchable’: Viewers Blast RNC, Fox for Including Univision in Debate

‘Donald Duck’: Trump, who skipped 2nd GOP presidential primary debate, targeted by competitors

September 27, 2023 | Alex Nitzberg | Leave a Comment

Seven Republican presidential hopefuls gathered at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in Simi … Read More... about ‘Donald Duck’: Trump, who skipped 2nd GOP presidential primary debate, targeted by competitors

Former President Trump Rallies in Detroit, Rails Against Automakers, Democrats, and Biden

September 27, 2023 | Susie Moore | Leave a Comment

While his GOP competitors were holding a debate at the Reagan Library in Simi Valley, California, … Read More... about Former President Trump Rallies in Detroit, Rails Against Automakers, Democrats, and Biden

Fact Check: Chris Christie Claims ‘Donald Duck’ Skipped Debate Because He is Afraid, Not Because He is Leading Polls

September 27, 2023 | Wendell Husebo | Leave a Comment

CLAIM: Republican primary presidential candidate Chris Christie claimed former President Donald … Read More... about Fact Check: Chris Christie Claims ‘Donald Duck’ Skipped Debate Because He is Afraid, Not Because He is Leading Polls

The Apprentice: GOP Primary Edition – Trump Slams Opponents as ‘Job Candidates’

September 27, 2023 | Nick Gilbertson | Leave a Comment

Former President Donald Trump bashed his Republican primary opponents on Wednesday while speaking to … Read More... about The Apprentice: GOP Primary Edition – Trump Slams Opponents as ‘Job Candidates’

High school French teacher under investigation over viral video of ‘hate speech’ against food vendor in California

September 27, 2023 | Carlos Garcia | Leave a Comment

A high school French teacher is under investigation after a viral video showed him yelling at a food … Read More... about High school French teacher under investigation over viral video of ‘hate speech’ against food vendor in California

Doug Burgum: Auto Workers Are Striking Against Biden’s Green Agenda

September 27, 2023 | John Binder | Leave a Comment

North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum (R) defended auto workers at the Republican presidential primary … Read More... about Doug Burgum: Auto Workers Are Striking Against Biden’s Green Agenda

Vivek Ramaswamy Calls for an End to Birthright Citizenship 

September 27, 2023 | Jordan Dixon-Hamilton | Leave a Comment

Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy called for an end to “birthright citizenship for … Read More... about Vivek Ramaswamy Calls for an End to Birthright Citizenship 

Univision Anchor Opens 2nd GOP Presidential Primary Debate in Spanish

September 27, 2023 | Amy Furr | Leave a Comment

A Noticias Univision anchor helped open the second Republican Presidential Primary debate on … Read More... about Univision Anchor Opens 2nd GOP Presidential Primary Debate in Spanish

Senate Passes ‘SHORTS’ Resolution; John Fetterman Must Wear Pants

September 27, 2023 | Joel B. Pollak | Leave a Comment

The U.S. Senate achieved a rare bipartisan milestone Wednesday when it passed the “SHow Our Respect … Read More... about Senate Passes ‘SHORTS’ Resolution; John Fetterman Must Wear Pants

Copyright © 2023 — FiercePatriots.com • All rights reserved. • Privacy Policy • Terms of Use • Sitemap